재량처분에 대한 사법심사기준 정량화 방안의 모색 - 챗GPT를 활용한 판례 데이터베이스 분석을 중심으로 -
Proposals for Quantifying the Standard of Judicial Review on Discretionary Dispositons - Analyzing a Case Database with ChatGPT -
- 발행
- 2023 등록이 논문은 발행 시점을 확인하지 못해 원문 등록일을 적었습니다. KCI가 2005~2008년에 옛 논문을 몰아서 올린 탓에, 그 시기 등록분은 발행보다 평균 3~5년 늦습니다. 실제 발행연도는 더 이를 수 있습니다.
- 소속·발행
- 법무법인 소헌/garimpark@gmail.com
- 출처
- 국내 KCI
- DOI
- 10.34267/cblj.2023.34.1.1
- 원문
- 원문 보기 ↗
개념
키워드
재량행위, 재량처분, 판례 데이터베이스, 비례원칙, 챗GPT, discretionary action, discretionary dispositon, judicial precedent database, the principle of proportionality, ChatGPT
초록
In previous cases related to judicial review of discretionary actions in administrative law, the focus has been on determining whether there was an abuse or deviation of discretionary power, resulting in insufficient assessment of individual reasons and explanation. Identifying specific reasons for judicial review of discretionary actions is necessary, as it influences the claims and evidentiary directions of the parties involved in administrative litigation and affects administrative authorities' actions. This study explores the possibility of quantitatively extracting individual judgment elements through attempts to concretize and typify the reasons for judicial review. As a premise for finding a quantitative method for judicial review criteria, Chapter 2 of this study collected and analyzed cases related to discretionary actions by building a database and utilized ChatGPT in the process. Although ChatGPT could not directly derive analytical results, it was confirmed that it could perform tasks that coding experts previously conducted and offer assistance in exploring analysis methods through question-and-answer interactions. Based on this analysis experience, Chapter 3 researche